Americans often underestimate the cost of health care. They also overestimate the price of some common health care procedures. Do Americans truly understand how much U.S. health care costs, and why do the real costs of medical procedures differ from the ideal price consumers want to pay for them?
We conducted a survey of 1,000 Americans to find out what they think health care should cost and then compared it to the reality of today’s medical price tags. Keep reading to find out what procedures may send you into debt and how the U.S. health care system stacks up compared to other developed countries.
Do Medical Visits Land You Over or Under Budget?
Are you putting off that doctor’s visit or dodging the dentist? Do you take your chances with the flu because you’re concerned you won’t be able to front the bill for the vaccination? How much money does it take to get these things done, and what visits are surprisingly more affordable than consumers guessed?
Americans both overestimated and underestimated the cost of medical procedures and doctor visits. In fact, Americans overestimated the cost of urgent care visits the most. The average estimated cost of a non-emergency urgent care visit was $456, while the actual cost averaged nearly 50 percent lower at $228.
Nearly 42 percent also overestimated the price of a trip to the dentist's office or flu vaccination. The average estimated cost was $205 for a dental exam and $68 for the flu shot. However, the actual costs for these services averaged $120 and $40, respectively.
Unfortunately, American consumers also underestimated the price of some common medical procedures. Americans underestimated the price of having their appendix removed by 115 percent. The estimated average cost of an appendectomy was $7,412. In reality, the actual cost averaged $15,930. To top it off, this is one of the most common acute surgical procedures in the nation, with 120 out of every 100,000 Americans having appendicitis in their lifetime, according to the Society of Laparoendoscopic Surgeons.
A visit to the hospital doesn’t run cheap, either. Americans underestimated the cost of a one-day hospital stay by 85 percent. And an emergency trip to the emergency room cost 34 percent more than expected. The only procedure that matched reality and perception was a C-section delivery. The estimated cost was $16,332, while the actual cost was slightly less at $16,106.
What Are Consumers Willing to Pay for Health Care?
It seems that perception and reality hardly align when it comes to the American health care system. Therefore, we posed another question: How much money do Americans feel they should be spending for these medical procedures? Once again, the actual costs overshadowed the ideal costs for American consumers.
It turns out, only one of these medical procedures costs less than what consumers wanted to pay. The flu shot was $15 cheaper than the average ideal cost of $55.
The remaining procedures had steeper costs. Bypass surgery had the largest price discrepancy with a $70,789 difference in what consumers wanted to pay versus what they were asked to pay. The same surgery can be conducted for a fraction of the price in the Netherlands, where it costs under $16,000.
Appendectomies cost $14,723 more than the ideal cost of $1,207. And when it came to hospital visits, Americans wanted to pay $497 for a one-day stay and $455 for an emergency visit to the ER. In reality, they would be asked to pay an average of $5,220 and $3,041 for these visits, respectively.
Taking a trip to the doctor or dentist may be more manageable, with much smaller relative price discrepancies of $110 and $38.
Is It Worth Going Into Debt for Health Care?
Emergencies, accidents and unforeseen health issues happen. But with such drastic price discrepancies for some of the most common medical procedures, how can Americans afford to pay the bill? What procedures are “worth it” when reality strikes?
We asked survey participants to rate different procedures on a scale of 1 to 5, with 1 being “not worth it” and 5 being “worth it” when it came to going into debt for medical procedures.
Two of the top 10 procedures were cancer treatments. Americans believed a pediatric cancer treatment averaged a 4.5, while adult cancer treatment averaged a 4.1.
Heart surgery was the second procedure deemed most worth going into debt over at 4.3. Other procedures that were considered “worth it” included a hospital birth (3.7), geriatric care (3.6), a diagnosis of unknown health issue (3.3) and mental health care (3.1).
Plastic surgery made the list a few times but was worth going into debt over for different reasons and at different levels. Americans said plastic surgery for children with disfigurements or genetic defects had a greater level of necessity at 3.7 on the scale. Plastic surgery for adults with an injury or disfigurement was considered a 2.8. And lowest on the list of procedures was plastic surgery unrelated to medical reasons. Cosmetic surgery to enhance one’s self-esteem only reached a 1.6 on the “worth it” scale.
Americans Find It's All Too Expensive
Do Americans consider U.S. health care affordable? We found the overwhelming majority said no. In fact, 88 percent of Americans said health care in the U.S. was not affordable. Additionally, 7 percent said it was affordable, while only 5 percent were unsure.
According to a study collectively published by Harvard, NPR, and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, more than a quarter (26 percent) of adults in the United States say health care costs have caused a serious financial problem for them as an individual or for their family. The second most common consequence of large medical bills in the nation was spending all or most of one’s personal savings (42 percent).
Comparing Health Care Costs
How does America compare to other developed countries when it comes to affordable health care?
When it came down to cost, more Americans thought U.S. health care cost too much compared to other developed countries. Thirty-two percent of Americans thought health care cost five times as much, while almost 18 percent thought it cost twice as much, 20 percent believed 10 times as much and 17 percent thought the price disparity was even greater than that.
In fact, Americans spend the most per person compared to other high-income countries, according to The Commonwealth Fund. In 2013, consumer spending on health care attributed for 17.1 percent of the nation’s gross domestic product, which was about 50 percent more than any other country. Increased spending is attributed to higher prices and more use of medical technology, such as diagnostic imaging exams, such as MRIs and CT scans.
Do higher prices equate to better quality? According to American consumers, 29 percent thought the quality of health care in the U.S. was equal to that of other developed countries. Twenty percent thought the quality was a little worse, and 22 percent thought it was a little better. Only 12 percent said they thought U.S. health care was a lot worse, while almost 14 percent said it was a lot better.
Although differing standards and practices make quality difficult to measure across the board, the high prices of American health care can limit access to care. According to the Peterson-Kaiser Health System Tracker, 37 percent of Americans reported cost-related barriers in 2013, compared to 4 percent in the United Kingdom and 22 percent in the Netherlands.
Another cost-related roadblock facing American consumers is that prescription drug prices are also extraordinarily high. According to The Economist, prices are high in the United States because the government does not implement price control on pharmaceuticals, unlike many European countries. Therefore, companies can name their price, making some medicines out of reach of American consumers who need them. And government-based insurance programs, such as Medicaid, get a mandated discount that may still be out of reach for some, while those using Medicare are one of the drug companies’ biggest consumers.
Americans Call for Health Care Reform?
There will always be differences of opinion over how a country should be run versus how it is operated. We asked American consumers what changes they would make to the U.S. health care system, and we collected the top 1,500 responses based on popular keywords.
Overall, American consumers based a majority of their responses on cost. The largest number of responses (18 percent) referenced affordability, while 12 percent said single-payer, 11 percent said free, 6 percent said cheaper and 5 percent said lower cost.
The United States is one of the only high-income countries that does not have universal health care, and 12 percent of participants used these keywords to describe their ideal reform. Another common keyword was insurance (13 percent).
Some less popular reform ideas included keywords, such as free (0.82 percent), better care (1 percent), eliminate Obamacare (2 percent), socialize (2 percent) and for everyone (1 percent). About 2 percent remained unsure of reformations they would consider making.
Protection Can Be Priceless
Despite differing perceptions on how the U.S. health care system stacks up in comparison to other countries, reality has a way of striking us all, sometimes when we least expect it.
Protection can be priceless, especially when it comes to the health of you or a loved one. Let insuranceQuotes.com find the insurance you can afford to help give you peace of mind for whatever may come your way. Contact one of our customer service agents today to get a free quote, so quality and affordability can become a reality when providing protection for you and your family on the road.
We surveyed 1,000 Americans about what they thought specific procedures and common medical expenses cost without insurance. We then compared answers to the actual average cost in the United States.
Fair Use Statement
Please use the information and images you find on this page freely for noncommercial use. But don’t get caught without insurance. Please make sure you link back to this page to give the author's full credit for the research.