If you’re one of the many people who celebrates this fun loving February holiday, Valentine’s Day gift spending is projected to hit record levels in 2026, and the modern gift list now includes pets, lab-grown engagement rings, experiences, and a whole lot of deliveries. So let’s dive in how you can fully feel the love this year while avoiding the most common “oops” moments in February 2026 inclduing: puppy love, jewelry and engagement rings, porch pirate headaches, candle mishaps, and even romance scams.
Love season is here—and so are the receipts
Valentine’s Day has always been about big feelings. In 2026, it’s also about big plans: dinner reservations, weekend getaways, sparkly surprises, and the kind of gifts that come with an additional heartbeat to love this February. The National Retail Federation (NRF) expects Valentine’s Day spending to reach a new record this year—$29.1 billion total, or about $199.78 per person on average.
Last year, we covered the classic “big-ticket Valentine’s moments”—jewelry, travel, cars, and even wedding/reception coverage. If you want a quick callback to see what’s changed: Valentine’s Day 2025: When Love Is Blind — Insurance Isn’t.
This 2026 update sticks with the same idea (keep the fun, lose the headaches), but leans into what’s trending right now: puppy gifting, pet Valentine baskets, lab-grown engagement rings, and a quick reality check on modern romance scams—so your gifts stay covered and your wallet stays intact this February.
🎶 …and they call it Puppy Love 🎶
Picture this: you hand your partner a big gift box wrapped in a red ribbon. They’re expecting jewelry… chocolates… champagne… maybe a giant teddy bear. Then the box starts to move. And suddenly there’s a soft little meow… or a tiny woof.
A puppy or kitten as a Valentine’s gift is basically a romantic-comedy shortcut to “new family member” status—and it’s one of the most 2026 things happening right now. With a new puppy or kitten being added to the family – you might be wanting to show some love to your new fur baby or the ones that have been keeping you in love for years.
NRF’s latest Valentine’s survey backs that up: 35% of shoppers plan to buy Valentine’s gifts for their pets this year, totaling $2.1 billion in pet-gift spending. Translation: it’s not just “flowers and chocolate” anymore. It’s also “heart-print pajamas and a treat box for your dog.”
And once there’s a dog or cat in the house, Valentine’s Day doesn’t stop with your human gift exchange. It usually turns into a second round of shopping—this time for the furry Valentine who now runs the household.
Valentine’s Day gifts for dogs and cats are booming
If you’ve ever said, “We’re not getting the dog anything,” and then somehow ended up with a heart-shaped toy and a bakery treat box… you’re in excellent company. Pet gifting is officially mainstream, and the trends are delightfully extra.
So What’s in the Top 2026 “Pet Valentine Basket” this year for the average dog owner?
Valentine dog pajamas (think pink, red, hearts, and the occasional “XOXO” slogan)
Heart-shaped treats with real ingredients (Valentine cookies, frosted biscuits, bakery bites)
Heart-shaped squeaky toys and plush “love” toys that somehow squeak forever
Bandanas, bow ties, and photo-ready accessories for the annual “we’re a cute family” picture
When Puppy Love is in the air:
One Texas business that really sees the pet-Valentine trend in action is Puppy Love Dog Store in Beaumont, TX—a fun (and impressively large) dog boutique known for premium treats, toys, all-natural dog foods, and seasonal finds that turn a “quick stop” into a full Valentine’s shopping experience – cause let’s face it, they deserve it and will always be your one true loves.
Owners Patti and Jeremy Vincent (a mom-and-son duo) shared how the holiday has become a bigger and bigger deal for fur-baby parents—especially when it comes to treats, themed toys, and quick photo moments:
“Over our 20 years in business at Puppy Love Dog Store, we’ve seen growing interest in Valentine’s gifts for pets. At least 85% of our customers include a Valentine treat for their dog—sometimes it’s an everyday favorite, and sometimes it’s a Valentine-specific cookie or toy. We also set up a Valentine backdrop so customers can take free photos of their dogs, and on Valentine’s Day every dog who comes into the shop receives a Valentine goodie bag from us. On average, customers spend about $15 to $45 on specialty goodies and gifts for their furry Valentine.” — Patti & Jeremy Vincent, Puppy Love Dog Store (Beaumont, TX)
Keeping Your Pets Healthy and Loved
And because love stories come with real-life logistics, it helps to know what you can do to keep your babies loved and safe for years to come. Pet insurance coverage is a great way to start, the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) summarizes industry data showing nearly 5.7 million pets were insured in the U.S. at year-end recently. Their data also lists average accident-and-illness premiums at about $56/month for dogs and $32/month for cats (averages vary by pet age, breed, and location).
Also worth knowing (especially if your dog’s love language is “enthusiastic greeting”): Triple-I/State Farm reports that dog bites and dog-related injury claims totaled 22,658 last year, with $1.57 billion paid and an average claim cost of $69,272. So always show love to your babies, but mishaps can happen — which covers the other side of being a loving and responsible pet parent across the board.
And once you’ve found the perfect gift for your one true furry love… it’s time to decide what to do for the humans in your life. That’s where the holiday’s other big spending category comes in: jewelry.
The 2026 ring story: bigger sparkle, smarter budgets
Engagement rings are still a Valentine classic—but the way people buy them has changed. Lab-grown diamonds have surged in popularity, and a trade report on the lab-grown market cites a Knot survey finding that 52% of engagement rings sold in the U.S. last year had a lab-grown diamond.
That shift helps explain why the “average ring budget” conversation is evolving. The Knot reports couples spent about $5,200 on average in 2024, while lab-grown and moissanite options keep rising because they can stretch budgets without giving up sparkle.
Jewelry insurance, without ruining the proposal: many homeowners and renters policies have jewelry sub-limits—especially for theft. Allstate gives an example of a $1,500 jewelry sub-limit after theft on a standard policy. If your ring is worth more than that, “scheduling” (itemizing) it can help match coverage to the item’s value.
A quick ring-protection mini-checklist: save your receipt, take a few photos, and ask your insurer one simple question: “If this ring is lost or stolen, what’s the max payout under my current policy?” (That answer is the difference between “no worries” and “oh no.”)
Now—if you’re not proposing, you might be doing the other big Valentine move: experience gifting. Dinner, concerts, weekend trips… basically anything that’s pre-paid and sometimes nonrefundable.
Experience gifts are up. So are nonrefundable plans.
Valentine’s can be a single dinner out… or it can turn into a full weekend getaway. Either way, the common thread is the same: deposits and reservations.
If you’ve ever been hit with a “sorry, no refunds” email, you already understand the basic point of travel insurance. InsureMyTrip notes travel insurance typically costs about 4% to 10% of your total trip price, depending on trip details and coverage options.
If travel gifts are in your future, do these three things:
Check what’s refundable before you buy anything else (airline, hotel, tickets).
If it’s nonrefundable and pricey, compare travel plans and look for trip cancellation/interruption coverage.
If you’re going international, look closely at medical coverage and emergency assistance benefits.
And whether you’re traveling or staying home, most Valentine plans include one universal ingredient: setting the mood. Which brings us to candlelight… and why it’s romantic and slightly risky.
Candlelight can be romantic. Candle mishaps are not.
If removing romantic candle light from your special day isn’t an option, then maybe adding coverage can be considered a loving gesture for your loved ones. NFPA research estimates that, on average, 21 home candle fires are reported per day (based on annual averages). So when the lights are low and the flames are burning here are some tips for keeping the love alive:
Mood-setting, but safer:
Keep candles at least 12 inches away from anything that can burn (curtains, décor, napkins).
Use stable holders and keep them where pets can’t tail-swipe them off a table.
Consider flameless candles if you’re hosting or you’ve got a curious cat in the house.
Next up: the delivery wave. Because no matter what you’re gifting, there’s a good chance it shows up in a box on your porch.
Porch pirates vs. Valentine deliveries
February is prime delivery season: surprise gifts, last-minute orders, and that one package you swear you ordered weeks ago. If something goes missing, renters insurance may help. Progressive notes that personal property coverage on renters insurance may cover your belongings if they’re stolen (up to coverage limits and minus your deductible), and it can also apply to items stolen from vehicles, storage units, or while traveling.
The part most people don’t think about until after the fact: deductibles and limits matter. If the item is inexpensive, a claim may not make sense—so prevention is the real Valentine hero here.
Low-effort ways to protect deliveries:
Require signature on high-value deliveries (or ship to a pickup location).
Use package lockers when available.
Time deliveries for when someone is home (or ask a neighbor to grab it).
And if your Valentine celebration is turning into an actual event—engagement party, venue rental, or a backyard setup with rentals—there’s one more coverage category people forget until the contract asks for it.
Pop-up proposals and mini-events: the quiet rise of event insurance
Not every Valentine plan is just dinner for two. People are hosting engagement parties, booking small venues, renting décor, and making deposits. If contracts and vendors are involved, event or wedding insurance can come up fast.
The Knot notes wedding insurance for a basic policy often ranges from $75 to $550, depending on provider, location, and coverage. They also note general liability coverage (often up to $1 million) can cost around $185.
At minimum, if you’re renting a space or bringing in vendors, scan your contract for liability requirements. It’s a 60-second check that can prevent a last-minute scramble.
Finally, we have to talk about the least romantic Valentine topic… but the one that can save people the most heartbreak. Because love season is also scam season.
A quick reality check: romance scams spike around Valentine’s Day
If you’re dating (especially online), Valentine’s week can come with extra attention—and unfortunately, extra scammers. The CFTC warns about romance/relationship frauds (including “pig butchering” confidence scams) and notes that in 2024 the FBI reported $5.8 billion in losses tied to crypto-asset-related investment frauds, with a large share linked to these relationship-driven schemes that you don’t want to fall for before the big day.
Red flags that deserve an immediate pause:
They move very fast (big declarations of love in days that involve monetary significant involvement).
They avoid video calls or in-person meetups with endless excuses.
They ask for money, gift cards, or crypto—or try to “teach you” a sure-thing investment because they love you so much.
They want secrecy or try to isolate you from friends/family feedback.
If you needed permission to be skeptical: this is it. The most romantic thing you can do for your future self is never mix brand-new love with money transfers this February.
The Valentine’s Day 2026 “Love List”
Here’s the quick checklist to keep the holiday fun and keeps love in the air.
If you bought jewelry: save receipts, snap photos, and ask about jewelry sub-limits or scheduling.
If you adopted a pet: plan for routine care, and consider whether pet insurance fits your budget.
If you’re traveling: check what’s refundable; if it’s not, compare travel coverage options.
If you’re using candles: keep them 12 inches away from anything that burns—and away from curious pets.
If you’re getting deliveries: use signature delivery or pickup options for high-value items.
If you’re dating online: don’t mix romance with money, crypto, or “investment opportunities.”
FAQs
Does homeowners or renters insurance cover an engagement ring? Often, yes—but many policies have jewelry sub-limits (especially for theft). If the ring is valuable, ask about scheduling it so coverage matches the item’s value.
Is pet insurance worth it? It depends on your budget and your pet’s needs. Triple-I summarizes industry data showing average accident-and-illness premiums around $56/month for dogs and $32/month for cats, but costs vary by pet and location.
How much does travel insurance usually cost? Many plans fall in the 4%–10% range of total trip cost, depending on trip details and coverage options.
What’s the biggest romance scam red flag? Any request for money, gift cards, or crypto—especially paired with urgency, secrecy, or a “can’t-miss” investment pitch.
Want to keep the romance simple and the insurance easy?
Compare quotes for auto, home, renters, and life insurance in minutes—so you can get back to the fun part of Valentine’s Day.
